What is the Shi'ite view of Islam?
Shi'ites share the same Qur'an, Prophet, and general beliefs as the Sunni Muslims.
There is, however, a difference in emphasis and in the order of precedence or ranking
of these fundamental beliefs and duties. This difference in precedence produces subtle
and yet deep shades of "coloring" that permeate the Muslim's attitude,
behaviour, and actions. The philosophical foundation (the coloring) of the belief
thus shifts slightly one way or the other and therefore what is built upon the foundation
shifts as well.
The difference of emphasis can be seen in the ranking of the basics of the creed
by Shi'ites. The usual (non-Shi'ite) ranking focuses primarily on action - on acting
out the basics of the religion. This is summarized in the well known five pillars
of Islam:
The Shi'ites obviously have no differences with the above pillars but they first lay a foundation upon which the pillars stand - in other words their emphasis is placed first on theological / philosophical (as derived from the Qur'an) principles and then the active dimension of the religion rests upon that foundation and in fact derives and emerges from that very foundation. The pillars are not free-standing pillars (that would be pointless - ask any architect) but rest on a foundation and support a larger structure. The Shi'ites begin with a somewhat different list of five fundamentals:
These principles then form the foundation of the acts of worship and the ethics of Islam which all Muslims are obliged to observe. The acts of worship are:
The dictates of ethics are called Tazkiya (Refining of the soul (self)) and (in a brief summary form) are as follows:
While most Muslims would follow much of the above, once again, the difference
is primarily one of emphasis, and of precedence and ranking. For Shi'ites it is an
article of Faith to be fully conscious of all of the principles, otherwise the actions
can degenerate into mere ritual or formality and the result would be a society where
the individual members carry out all these actions and their impact and significance
is almost non-existent. In other words, the actions alone won't bring about reform
in an individual and in a society and in the world. The actions must be founded upon
comprehensive principles that are well understood. Only then can one's intention
be truly pure and clear. And once this happens the actions will bring about profound
change as they did in the Prophet's time.
The single greatest distinction is the concept of the Imamate. For Shi'ites the most
important function after the death of the Prophet(s.a.) was the clarification of
Islamic teachings and the preservation of the Sunna of the Prophet(s.a.). The Shi'ites
look to the Ahl al-bait (the household of the Prophet(s.a.)) and the Imams for the
complete and perfect understanding of the sunna and as models and examples of that
sunna being put into practise. And after the Prophet(s.a.), they (the Imams) were
the "keepers of the book", the explainers of the Qur'an, since the Prophet
had taught them from his own knowledge far beyond the extent that he taught any other
companions. He was Ali's personal teacher on a daily basis from the day of the declaration
of his Prophethood(s.a.) to the day he died.
It is a simple matter that there was no one else as qualified in knowledge or in
personal behaviour as the Ahl al-bait and the Imams. They were the best means of
preserving and conveying correctly the sunna of the Prophet (s.a.). So the Imams
are like Islamic technicians - they understand Islam and they take care of it. They
do not merely hear it and pass it on. For the Shi'ites, the Imams are the preservers
of the pure Islam of the Prophet (s.a.) and they are followed whether they hold political
power or not.
The Prophet(s.a.) had asked Muslims to look to Ali for the correct leadership so
the Shi'ites did just that whether Ali was in a position of political power or not
- Political and social leadership was only a small part of Imamate - its main function
was the preservation of the purity of Islam (its goal was a long term goal that had
to survive the squabbles for power and empire that swept the Muslim world from the
time of the Umayyads onwards and to preserve Islam from the distortions created by
the Umayyads and other succeeding empires).